As we continue our ‘Tithing on Trial’ series, we will evaluate the most common tithing arguments used to defend its practice. So let’s evaluate another argument used to promote tithing. This argument comes directly from a well-known author on finances from Crown Financial Ministries – Larry Burkett. He has now passed, but we are going to evaluate his argument below taken from his book, “Giving & Tithing.”
While reading through the book, “TIthing & Giving” by Larry Burkett I came across a section that asked, “Is Tithing Legalism”? In the beginning, Larry states, “Although the tithe is mentioned in the law, no punishment was indicated for not tithing. There is a consequence (the loss of blessings), but there is no punishment from God for not tithing.”
What happened when Israel didn’t tithe?
I am not sure where Larry Burkett is getting his information about tithing in the bible, but you have to know that there certainly was a curse on Israel for not tithing. Malachi 3:9 states, “You are cursed with a curse, For you have robbed me.”
Malachi 3:11 goes on, “And I will rebuke the devourer for your sakes, So that he will not destroy the fruit of your ground, Nor shall the vine fail to bear fruit for you in the field,“
I don’t think there is any question about the curse for Israel not tithing. We can find further proof in the book of Deuteronomy when God is laying out the laws for Israel. In chapter 26 he outlines the rules for tithing and by chapter 28 beginning in verse 15, God outlines in the next 50 verses the curses and punishments that would come upon them for not obeying his commands that were just laid out.
What Happens When Your Don’t Tithe?
As counterintuitive as it may sound, when we don’t tithe the opposite of what happened to Israel happens to us as Christians. The answer is that when we don’t tithe, we are blessed. Here are five reasons we are blessed for not tithing.
- You are under grace (Romans 6:14)
- God said He would supply all our needs without mentioning the tithe (Philippians 4:19)
- Our gifts are a sweet-smelling sacrifice that is acceptable and pleasing to God (Philippians 4:18)
- God Loves a Cheerful giver. (2 Corinthians 9:7)
- The Spirit gives life (Romans 8:5-10)
As Christians, we should have confidence in these new promises under grace and the blessings that come with them. There is a caveat that I want to mention. Even though there are no consequences of not paying tithes, and we receive some inherent benefits and blessings, our greatest blessing comes when we give freely without obligation instead of giving a tithe.
This is not an excuse to give nothing. We should be willing to give from the love of our hearts. God has given us so much that it should compel our hearts to give back as he sacrificially gave to us. This is not an external force compelling us to give. This is an internal force that aligns with our heart’s attitude.
Are We Cursed When We Don’t Tithe?
Even though we receive a blessing for not tithing, some may still be wondering about the curse for not tithing and did it go away. The answer is no, God does not curse us if we don’t tithe. We are no longer under the curse of the law. We are under grace. You are cursed if you do tithe and blessed if you don’t.
If you don’t practice tithing, you are free from the curse, free from the law, and free from tithing. So many feel led to give to someone outside their church but are terrified to do so because of the fear of the curse. It’s not that they don’t like their church or disagree, but in their heart, they have the desire to fill a more urgent need. When people pass up the opportunity to give from their hearts, they invite doubt or even guilt in their hearts, which robs them of their blessing.
The problem with Larry Burkett and others with the same mentality towards tithing are that they know that tithing looks out of place when we attempt to fit it into a Church that is not supposed to be governed by the law. So they modify its appearance a little bit and make tithing more user-friendly than what it was in the Old Testament. The deception is that if we can mix in a little grace by disassociating it from the curse, then the tithe will appear as if it fits right in there with the other principles we practice today. This reformulation of the tithe is nothing but the law dressed up in grace’s clothing.
THE LAW + GRACE + LENIENCY = THE LAW
You Be the Judge
Now that the evidence has been given in this court of law, it is your turn to decide. You be the judge.
What does it mean when Jesus was talking to the Pharisees and said you should tithe yes. My pastor points this out and says this is proof Jesus wants us to tithe.
People was still under the law because Jesus had not died yet. So no one could be saved by grace yet…meaning people were still under the law and cursed if they did follow all of the law.
Yes Jesus already died for us in the cross he took all of our sins curses and he is alive he rose from the dead
imagine if everyone stopped tithing. wouldn’t the churches disappear? don’t they depend on tithes to exist?
No the churches would not disappear. When was a young girl, now 79 my grandparents didn’t tithe they paid dues accosting their income. I remember her giving $2.00 and Mr Johnny Johnson gave .10.00. The church never closed.
Glory!!!! To God we are NOT UNDER a curse We Give out of Gratitude being Thankful for everything Jesus has done for our salvation. Nothing but the precious Blood ? of Jesus keeps the doors open Not man
Amen
Dues accosting (according to their income would be tithe.
Tithing is a most if you want to prosper. The commandments of God are in the old testament and e are still following it tithing can not be exception. If you don’t pay your tithe one will also not make to heaven and things will be tithe a you will be counting loss instead of gain. Remain Blessed.
Please show me where scripture in the New and Old Testament conclude what you’re saying. If that’s you opinion, that’s your opinion. If you’re saying it’s a Biblical fact. The burden of proof should easily be found in both the Old and New Testament rightly dividing the word of truth.
I cannot latch on to whatever discussion was taking place before but I do know the Word says this in the OT on tithes:
“Will a mere mortal rob God? Yet you rob me. “But you ask, ‘How are we robbing you?’ “In tithes and offerings. You are under a curse—your whole nation—because you are robbing me. Bring the whole tithe into the storehouse, that there may be food in my house. Test me in this,” says the Lord Almighty, “and see if I will not throw open the floodgates of heaven and pour out so much blessing that there will not be room enough to store it. I will prevent pests from devouring your crops, and the vines in your fields will not drop their fruit before it is ripe,” says the Lord Almighty. “Then all the nations will call you blessed, for yours will be a delightful land,” says the Lord Almighty.”
??Malachi? ?3?:?8?-?12? ?NIV??
If we must subtract tithing then the 10 commandments are meaningless and irrelevant.
believing in Jesus gets us to heaven (His blood), not the tithe.
i disagree. tithing has nothing to with salvatin.
Jesus was NOT supporting the tithe here. The point of that conversation was that these people were practicing certain rules under the law while ignoring weightier and more important matters. Jesus had every opportunity to remind Christians to tithe, yet he didn’t. Paul also in 2 Corinthians 9 had every opportunity to remind those believers to not only give, but also tithe. He didn’t.
Jesus was talking about the law ! But now we’re under Grace cause Jesus died for us ! 2Corinthans 9 :7 says So let each one give as he purposes in his heart, not grudgingly or of necessity, for God loves a cheerful giver
We are under grace, which is through faith as mentioned in hebrews, Abraham believed God and it was credited to him as righteousness, Abraham also tithed to Melchizadek a tenth, so tithing predates the law, if Abraham is justified by faith which we claim then the principle of tithing applies
amen…tithing was a command for Israel…when Yeshua died the law died abd we the church practice under grace…we are not commanded to tithe..neither was all of Israel and those who were.. had to give more than 10%…and the reference to tithing was just about money..so just give as you are blessed
First and foremost Jesus didn’t came to this world to abolish the law but he came to fulfil the law. So “God love the cheerful giver” this doesn’t mean don’t tithe but it mean give more than ten tithe with cheerful heart. So here my question is that “are we really give enough offerings? Are we really giving more than ten tithes with joy ?
I think most of today’s Christians are compromising the Holy Bible with human understanding. Better rooted in the word of God. Both OT and NT still applicable in our era.
Who ever wrote this article contradicted himself. He said we should not tithe because we are not under the law. Paul said because we are not under the law, is it OK to kill, steal, commit adultery?
You say this statement as if there’s been no change between the Mosaic covenant and the new covenant. The truth is, people know why tithing is under the law, but are too addicted to the fleshly stimulant of financial control. This addiction turned to tradition, and continues on due to ignorance. This site, and many others, are here to reverse this trend.
Fatuous argument, we are not bound to keep the six hundred plus laws of Moses, Jesus said the law could summed up in two commands, love the lord your God and love your neighbour as yourself, killing, stealing and adultery don’t fit with these
not tithing is not loving God; because God should be first in your finances. Have no other gods before Me, He says.
Matthew 5:17-20 Jesus said I have not come to abolished the law but to redeemed it and He continues that heaven and earth will past away but everything written in the book will not pass without being fulfill. So if Jesus can say these are try to say that old testament books is relevant again, and I don’t think tithing is law but a command
Matthew 5:17, my sister, if you understand that scripture very well, you will discover that this words are Jesus’ polite was of saying “I have come to abolish the law or make it go away”
He couldn’t come plain because he was still in the law’s era and “wisdom is profitable to direct”. Remember when He said “they will hear but not understand”?
Matthew 5 (KJV)
¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯
¹? Think not that I am come to destroy the law, or the prophets: I am not come to destroy, BUT TO FULFIL.
¹? For verily I say unto you, Till heaven and earth pass, one jot or one tittle shall in no wise pass from the law, TILL ALL BE FULFILLED.
So according to this statement of The Master, the only condition for the law to pass is to “BE FULFILLED”, And see why Jesus came in verse 17, “TO FULFILL”. So one would ask, did Jesus failed in the mission that He came for or did He actually FULFILL? let’s find what Romans said
Romans 8 (KJV)
¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯¯
³ For what the law could not do, in that it was weak through the flesh, God sending his own Son in the likeness of sinful flesh, and for sin, condemned sin in the flesh:
? That the righteousness of the law might be FULFILLED in us, who walk not after the flesh, but after the Spirit.
so this could be clearer
Galatians 3:23-26 NLT
[23]Before the way of faith in Christ was available to us, we were placed under guard by the law. We were kept in protective custody, so to speak, until the way of faith was revealed.
[24]Let me put it another way. The law was our guardian until Christ came; it protected us until we could be made right with God through faith.
[25]And now that the way of faith has come, we no longer need the law as our guardian.
[26]For you are all children of God through faith in Christ Jesus.
“For Christ is the end of the law for righteousness to every one that believeth.”
— Romans 10:4 (KJV)
Galatians 4:1-6
[1]Think of it this way. If a father dies and leaves an inheritance for his young children, those children are not much better off than slaves until they grow up, even though they actually own everything their father had.
[2]They have to obey their guardians until they reach whatever age their father set.
[3]And that’s the way it was with us before Christ came. We were like children; we were slaves to the basic spiritual principles of this world.
[4]But when the right time came, God sent his Son, born of a woman, subject to the law.
[5]God sent him to buy freedom for us who were slaves to the law, so that he could adopt us as his very own children.
[6]And because we are his children, God has sent the Spirit of his Son into our hearts, prompting us to call out, “Abba, Father.”
See also Luke 16:16 Hebrews 8 and 9, pls take note of verse 7 and 13 of chapter 8. See also Galatians 5:1-4( if you have NLT bible then read till the end for comprehensive understanding
Every single time I stop tithing, something bad happens that costs me a lot of money. Like, something with my car goes wrong and I’m out a few grand for not tithing. I know that sounds weird but it’s true. I’ve stopped multiple times to have multiple bad things happen costing me more than if I were tithing.
That’s odd cause I don’t tithe and I’m blessed. Either way something bad does come up but that’s when you are supposed to rely on God to provide in times of fear and need
Bad things happen to you because you are willingly allowing yourself to be under the law. Galatians 3:10 says “But those who depend on the law to make them right with God are under his curse, for the Scriptures say, “Cursed is everyone who does not observe and obey all the commands that are written in God’s Book of the Law.””
??Galatians? ?3?:?10? ?NLT??
So we can see that you’re dependent upon the law to make you right. Yet you don’t follow all of the over 613 commands under the law in the Old Testament. So you’re cursed for not following all the law. That’s why bad things happen to you. If you want to be blessed, stop tithing and start living under the grace of God.
That’s giving out of necessity, there’s a million things that can go wrong in any given day. God is not punishing you because you’re not paying a tithe. He owns the Cattle on a thousand hills and all the Taters under ‘em. Giving because you believe it’s the right thing to do is between you and God.
Give of your time and talent until your able to tithe. ?
I’ve made a post about your situation sometimes ago on my fb, https://www.facebook.com/100007556501167/posts/pfbid02ZcmvmozgKmbSnhu6Zo8JH9jc9zxwN1xhAPZ7pxcY4aUv5pNorGRNs3eT9m978iQBl/?app=fbl
The truth is that the devil will not watch you go easy, moreover you are still under the law by will,
It happens to me when I stop tithing.
I don’t practice tithing , or try to keep any of the old testament law. I just ask God to lead me in what he wants me to do. That’s it, simple! Either we’re led by the Holy Spirit which is the better New covenant, or we’re driven by the law and live a life full of guilt, condemnation and lack. I used to try to keep the law by tithing and all I ever got was cursed. I didn’t understand the scripture that says everyone who tries to keep the law becomes cursed. Now I realize Jesus fulfilled all the law, because no one else could, and all I have to do now is allow him to lead me in everything I do and say by His Holy Spirit. I just purpose to keep these 2 commandments the best I can: love Him with my whole heart, mind and strength, and love my neighbor as myself. Jesus reduced all the law into these 2 commandments. Thank you JESUS!!!
The problems in the contemporary church is their incorrect teaching about tithing. What I mean is they have poor accountability and stewardship with the tithe money. This comes a lot of times from the pastor’s lust for the things of this world when their salary can’t pay for what covet. So whatver you give as a true christian give as you are convinced(convicted by the Holy Spirit with the joy of giving a tithe or offering. We mustn’t judge another man or a woman’s conviction about giving.The Problem also that I see in the present N.T.church is the thinking they’re under the curse of the law but Jesus has broken the curse of the law. So those that are now in christ are blessed by keeping his commandments as he commands they should be follow to be blessed. Did Jesus not state if you love me, keep my commandments. For his commandments are not grievous(burdensome). The disagreement in the body of Christ nowadays is what all those commandments are. Further study shows that they are based on the ten commands but summed up in the two greatest commandments.
What I don’t like about the argumentative exegetic attitude of some in this discussion is each one is saying the other one is cursed based on another one’stheological perception and using some scripture out of context.
Just remember what the New Testament teachs says that anything that’s done out of fear is sin. For the righteous shall live by faith. Galatians 3:11, Roman 1:17, and Hebrews 10:38. The commandments of God have a place in the new Testament but not to count on them for salvation but rather the one that fufill the law for us and took away the curse, Jesus Christ. So whether you tithe or not and do not have Christ in your life then you’re cursed by the curse regarding the tithe as well as the other laws. Neither is there a salvation in any other: for there is none other name under heaven given amongst men’ where my we must be saved.
The righteous shall live by faith. They all did that both the saints and patriarchs in the old and New Testament. Habakkuk 2:4, Hebrews 10:38, Galatians 3:11, Roman 1:17, So bottom line Give, and it shall be given unto you: good measure, pressed down, and shaken together. and running over; you measure press down and shake it together, everyone in ogre shall men give into your blossom. For with the measure that ye mete withal it shall be measured to you again.entitled version for with the same measure that you met with all you shall be measured to you again. The applies to offerings, tithe, service,love et cetera.
Tithing is a personal thing. That’s between you and God. He knows your heart. I do believe it to be a little much to say you’re cursed for tithing.
Not for tithing but depending on tithing to keep you from curse only.
No. It is not personal. It is voluntary compliance.
Thank you for this vital information because the church that I was a member of the pastor and his official made members very uncomfortable by saying that if you don’t pay your tithing that you will be cursed with a curse and that all your blessings that you received will be destroyed and he used to preach about that atleast two Sunday out of the month from the Old Testament so he preached about the Law and not the grace but I payed my tithing faithfully out of fear of being cursed and me and my wife was the cooks of the church and we used our own money and stamps with no
Donation because we didn’t ask and none was offered
Oh my gosh! I have just been set free! If I try to keep any part of the law, I am no more under GRACE, and will be cursed because no one can keep the law! Such freedom to rightly divide the WORD of TRUTH! Amen!
Amen! A weight lifted off. The ?nemy is so sneak! Lord let us look to Your face and word. We long for Your heart. Show us how to be faithful with what you have given us. We are willing!
Malachi chapter 3and4 was the prophecies about the first coming and the second coming of our lord Jesus Christ. Spiritually this book of Malachi remind us to get well prepared our selves as we are waiting Jesus for the second coming. The greatest spiritual tithe we give is to repent and hearts to because bodies are the temple’s of God. Genesis to revelation we should preach Christ for what he has done at the Calvary.
I have a question. I have not tithed for many years now, and I feel like I am on a streak of increasing downwards trajectory towards the murky black that lies at the bottom. 2 years ago, I was smoking by the fields, close to harvest-time, when suddenly I was plummeting forwards at a great rate; I was puzzled, as there was no wind that day, although after the fact I would discover that it was a falling branch from my apple tree. Much to my despair the cigar I had been happily smoking was gone ! I resigned to my abode to recuperate, and the next I knew, my crop was ablaze! Since then, It has been repeated and continuous mishaps of the same caliber and I am not sure how much longer my feeble mind and body can withstand this punishment. I come looking for support and comfort in my darkest hour, and I come with the hope of reconciling any last relationship I have with HIM and the church as a whole.
For we walk by faith, not by sight,
Gerald
I agree with those who are saying, tithing is between that person and God. I think people Mus t be conscious to the Holy Spirit when commenting on the word,of God. I see harshness in some of our comments, which I think God will not be happy with them. Tithing is principle which was there before the Mosaic Law. Abraham practiced and was blessed. And the Lord was happy with it, then He encorporated in the law. It is not law, lt was not law, but a principled command of God. It is still relevant in our churches – But should be done freely and willingly like the Abraham did. He was not compelled but did it out of his Will and freely. Those who say there were cursed because of tithing should mind their words. That will not happened when doing the word of God. I just think they are street pastors who are on track of misleading the church for their personal gains.
If I tithe I am cursed and if I don’t tithe I am blessed and tithe is not directly mentioned in the Big Ten commandments. Then going by your teaching we can then also say, ” I will dishonour my parents that I may not be under a curse. But blessed??!!! The Law is Holy, the problem was not the Law But the flesh, Romans 8:3 For what the Law could not do, in that it was weak through the flesh……
Verse 4 That the RIGHTEOUSNESS ( Righteous requirements) of the Law might be fulfilled in us who WALK not after the flesh,but after the Spirit
Matthew 5:17 Think not that I Am come to destroy the Law…….. not come to destroy but to fufill. In Christ Jesus we fufill the Law, we don’t struggle to Obey God, put Him first in our live’s, tithe, honour our parents, Love not only our neighbors but even our enemies,
Galatians 5:14 But strong meat belongs to them who are of full age, even those who by reason of use have their senses exercised to discern both good and evil.
Is Tithing Evil?
To stay in your house watching television on a sabbath when other believer’s are gathering together which is good and which is Evil?
May God help us.
Christ fulfilled the law and rendered it obsolete for righteousness sake. Our righteousness now comes from Jesus, not the law. Romans 10:4.
Understanding this, the spirit of giving comes via Holy Spirit, not law. If a person feels compelled by God to offer 9.9% and not 10%, they have done what was holy. If they are compelled to give 27% and only give 25%, they have not done what was holy.
We follow the guidance of the Holy Spirit in our giving. Paul taught believer to pray and give accordingly. If believers were to follow law, there would be no need to pray about what to give.
Malachi chapter 3and4 was the prophecies about the first coming and the second coming of our lord Jesus Christ. Spiritually this book of Malachi remind us to get well prepared our selves as we are waiting Jesus for the second coming. The greatest spiritual tithe we should give is to repent and give our hearts to Jesus. Genesis to revelation we should preach Christ for what he has done at the Calvary.
The person who said that this teaching about tithing come from Street preachers which I call Jack leg preachers, I agree with. Because I have never heard so much biblical illiterate teaching in all of my 71 years of living.
The writer doesn’t make sense. Many condemn tithe because of greed.
Can you refuse to tax. Does it pain you when you see politicians driving V8 ?can you them ?
The Antichrist will twist the word of God into a holy lie only to derail children of God from their blessings.
Tithing is a command and it carry both blessings and a course.
“God said He would supply all our needs without mentioning the tithe (Philippians 4:19)”
But in context Paul said this after he received tithes and offerings. In fact, Paul said “I have received full payment…” What was full payment?
I have an even better question for all those claiming tithing is no longer applicable.
Jesus said “Give unto Caesar what is Caesar’s and give unto God what is God’s”. So how do we know what is God’s? Whatever is in our heart? “Our hearts are wicked”. We can know what is God’s by going to God’s word. In fact “All scripture is given by inspiration of God, and is profitable for doctrine, for reproof, for correction, for instruction in righteousness: That the man of God may be perfect, thoroughly furnished unto all good works.”
When this was written to Timothy the scripture being referred to is the Torah. The Torah was clear on what God’s portion was since the very beginning it has been the first fruits and the tithe. Abraham tithed before the law and if you study it so did Cain and Able.
Gods promises still to stand and if God said “Test me in this and see if I do not pour out to you the windows of Heaven” Malachi 3. Do you think God changes HIS mind and HE no longer will honor HIS promise if we test HIM as HIS word says? I’ve yet to find anyone who has tested God and have HIM not fulfill HIS word!
The devil would like nothing more than for people to believe Gods word is no longer true.
The most bizarre teaching I have ever heard, filled with absurdity, is, “When we don’t tithe, we are blessed because we are no longer under the cures of the law but under grace.” Tithing has nothing to do with the law but rather a command from the Lord. What makes the law a curse is no one is justified in fulfilling the requirements of the law. The law is fulfilled in the believer’s life by what Jesus Christ did on the cross of Calvary. Jesus became for us through His death. Through His death, we are saved by grace through faith in Him. To say that “If we don’t tithe, we are blessed ” overturns God’s grace, because it is God’s grace that enables the Christian to tithe, and not the other way around.
I most definitely tested God in this, and He failed big time. I started tithing and God not only did not ‘open the floodgates’, he didn’t even provide for our most basic and needs and brought about total financial ruin from which I will never recover. I kept making ever excuse in the book for over 9 years….maybe this year will be better, but God never showed up, never came through. All He did was make things even worse for me, after decades of failing to provide and destroy all the faith I had.
Yes and Amen!
What about taxes.We are under grace we dont need pay taxes.
Taxes are govern by our government, county and cities. I hate paying taxes just like everyone else but if we didn’t pay them who would pay for our schools, police force, roads, etc. and those individuals who run them.
I personally believe that God doesn’t need anything from us ..its us showing our faithfulness to God by giving tithes ..before law adam son and Abraham both gives offering to god so its not a old and new covenant but it’s a faithfulness towards god..not 10 but we can give freely more than that…all belongs to him ..
God , Jesus gave it all , I give Abraham’s tithes as not one tittle ofthe law will be erased. I give because I want to , out of appreciation to God . Our lives are a Holy sacrafice back to God thru our trials Up or down. I think God looks at the heart not by the law we are saved under Grace . We are so blessed as children of God Amen ( so be it )
In Malachai 3, God was speaking to the priests. He was not telling them to tithe. He was telling to bring the whole tithe they collected from the flock to the storehouse. They were stealing. God was addressing theft, not proper tithing.
When Abraham tithed to Melchizedek (Priest/King), he gave Melchizedek his spoils of war, not his personal belongings. In addition, King Melchzedek blessed Abraham BEFORE Abraham gave anything at all.
Tithing to your church is voluntary compliance. I encourage everyone who loves the Lord to tithe to your church. For those who don’t tithe, why don’t you try it? Just try it. Don’t argue. Just try it. Here is my testimony on my tithing…
Like some of you I was doubtful about tithing. I felt conviction for not tithing and my lifestyle certainly demonstrated that. I was living under poverty and just scraping a living. Basic modest apartment, basic clothing. Basic transportation. Basic food. In other words my life was very basic.
The God laid it upon my heart to try it, and so I complied. Over the years I have seen improvements in my life. I now able to maintain a cash flow, my standard of living is much better, God blessed my appraisal business, and I was able to afford to do more things I was unable to do such as live in a much nicer home, being able to travel the world, driving a late model car, just to name several.
So what happens when I intentionally did not tithe? I suffered some consequences. Mostly financial. Car break downs. Visits to the vet to treat my dog, unexpected bills and even a lawsuit. The amounts that I had to pay were the amounts I should have given from my heart.
In the long run God has always met my needs. He would make sure my financial obligations were met… mortgage, car payments, loans, and even fulfilled my desires.
So my brothers and sisters in Christ please don’t look for excuses not to tithe. Good loves a cheerful giver. Try it. Please. Just do it.
Why should we tithe? Well, it helps pays the salaries for the church staff. It pays for the church bills. It helps also to pay for missions and it helps the betterment to spread the Gospel. In most churches the 80%/20% rule applies. 80% of the financial givings come from 20% from the church congregation.
If you are a Mormon and don’t tithe, they will send their Bishops and Elders after you to collect their tithes.